Monday, August 15, 2011

Two Reagans

As the years pass the Ronald Reagan administration looks worse and worse. Well, at least half of it does (more on that later). One of the best indications of the relative success of Reagan's economic policies is the incredibly poor quality of the writing that seeks to defend them.

This morning's USA Today offers an excellent example. In an essay entitled "The Reagan Stimulus vs. the Obama One" Paul G. Kengor seeks to show how Reagan's tax cut stimulus was a rousing success while Obama's fiscal stimulus was a complete failure. The essay gets off to a shaky start:
Reagan's initiative was the antithesis of President Obama's $800 billion "stimulus" that didn't stimulate. The 2009 version was the single greatest contributor to our record $1.5 trillion deficit. It was, plain and simple, what Reagan didn't do.
Obama's stimulus didn't stimulate? All of the independent economic analysts (CBO, Moody Analytics, etc.) that have looked at the 2009 Recovery Act have concluded that it achieved just about what the administration said it would. The problem wasn't the effectiveness of the stimulus. As I have written here before, the problem was that the economic hole we were in was much deeper than anyone knew at the time. This is not opinion. Recent revisions of GDP data have confirmed this. We are entering a very weak economic patch right now at least partly because the effects of the stimulus are pretty much over.

The stimulus was the "single greatest contributor to our record $1.5 trillion deficit"??? This one is a real howler. Anyone even marginally familiar with the data knows that the CBO predicted in January 2009 that the deficit for 2009 would be well above $1 trillion. This is BEFORE the stimulus was even proposed, and certainly before any of its provisions had taken effect. The deficit exploded in 2009 not because of the stimulus, but because of the financial crisis--tax receipts shrank and automatic safety net programs (unemployment insurance, food stamps, etc.) went up.

The opening paragraph pretty much sets the tone for the remainder of the essay, which is a hagiographic combination of remembered Reagan through a filter of selective amnesia and rose-colored glasses. He continues to extoll the virtues of the Reagan tax cuts:
The enemy that day was America's progressive federal income tax system. . . .
After a slow start through 1982-83, the stimulus effect of the cuts was extraordinary, sparking the longest peacetime expansion in U.S. history. The "Reagan Boom" not only produced widespread prosperity but—along with the attendant Soviet collapse—also helped generate budget surpluses in the 1990s.

Again, none of the primary claims in these two paragraphs are true. First, the main obstacle to economic growth in the first two years of the Reagan administration had nothing to do with tax rates. The chairman of the Federal Reserve, Paul Volker, had decided that he was going to once and for all wring inflation out of the American economy. He did this by severely restricting the money supply and raising interest rates to 21%. This is not a typo. Volker's plan worked, lowering inflation from 13.5% in 1981 to 3.2% by 1983. However, in the interim it had a devastating effect on the economy, which experienced the deepest recession since the 1930s. However, when Volker decided to declare victory over inflation and lower interest rates back to normal levels, the economy exploded. In comparison to this, the effects of Reagan's tax cuts was quite small. Indeed, the first round of tax cuts when the economy grew the fastest left the top rate at 50%, much higher than the 35% of today.

Second, Reagan devotees never tire of repeating the "longest peacetime expansion in U.S. history" line, despite the face that it simply isn't true. The Reagan expansion lasted 32 quarters from the Q4 1982 through Q3 1990. Pretty good, eh? Well, not as good as the 40 quarters of expansion from Q2 1991-Q4 2000 that began during the Bush I administration and continued throughout all of the Clinton years. Moreover, the Clinton expansion saw better job growth than the Reagan years (23 million jobs vs. 16 million jobs) and much better budget results, with Clinton leaving a substantial surplus and Reagan leaving a substantial deficit. Lastly, the Clinton economic performance occurred after two increases in the top marginal income tax rates, first in 1990 under Bush I (28% to 31%) and then again under Clinton in 1993 (31% to 39.5%). How Reagan's economic policy was responsible for economic growth during the Clinton administration is not explained. One might just as well argue that the economic policies of LBJ were responsible for all the good that occurred during the Reagan years.

In any case, comparing the Obama stimulus to the initial Reagan tax cut is a particularly pointless exercise, since the economic conditions that preceded them were wildly different. Reagan dealt with high inflation and high interest rates, but the Obama stimulus was passed during a deflationary period when interest rates were near zero.

Kengor feels it necessary to respond to the "myth" that Reagan's tax cuts were responsible for the deficit by pointing out "Tax revenues under Reagan rose from $599 billion in 1981 to nearly $1 trillion in 1989. The problem was that outlays all along outpaced revenue, soaring from $678 billion in 1981 to $1.14 trillion in 1989." The $599 billion in 1981 that Kengor cites was 19.6% of GDP that year. The nearly $1 trillion in 1989 he cites was 18.4% of GDP. Ironically, over the same period and using the very data he cites, spending went down as a percentage of GDP from 22.2% to 21.2%. So, even the data he cites demonstrates exactly the opposite of what he claims. Not only is it not a "myth" that the Reagan tax cuts caused the Reagan deficits, his own data proves it.

However, there was another Reagan, the Reagan of foreign policy achievements. In this arena Reagan was much more successful. His Teddy Rooseveltian policy of speaking softly and carrying a big stick was effective in helping to win the Cold War. He did not do this alone, as many Reagan sycophants insist. He had a lot of help from a Polish Pope, a Polish labor leader, and a man by the name of Mikhail Sergeyevich Gorbachev. Had Gorbachev been willing to fire on his own people to prevent change, events in the eastern block would have turned out differently. Nonetheless, Reagan deserves his not insubstantial share of the credit. Unfortunately, it is this aspect of the Reagan administration--the truly successful part--that contemporary Republicans have almost completely forgotten. Be strong, yes, but engage your enemies with relentless negotiation is an approach that the Bush II administration abandoned.

Even on tax policy, Reagan's demonstrable flexibility on the subject--lowering taxes when he could, but raising taxes when necessary--is an anathema to the modern GOP. Too bad.

Saturday, August 13, 2011

Sarah as Kim

Has it occurred to anyone else what an attention whore Sarah Palin is? She shows up at Ames during the Iowa straw poll event--an event that is part of an election she is not a candidate in--just to bask in the attention she gets. Mike Huckabee isn't running either and he is there also, but at least he is playing guitar for several of the candidates.

The woman is the Kim Kardashian of the political world without the sex tape.

Friday, August 5, 2011

A Twofer

This is the first time I have referenced the same columnist's work twice in a row, but David Frum is on a roll.

A must read.

Less Politics, More Economics

Thursday, August 4, 2011

Frum and the opening of the American mind

David Frum has two great columns that anyone interested in the current economic calamity should read.

Were our Enemies Right?

If Conservatives Were Right About the Economy

These are written by a man who has not changed his core beliefs, but who is also willing to subject his beliefs to empirical data.

Friday, July 29, 2011

What if the Two Parties were Alike?

Jonathan Chait asks this question and envisions an era of unprecedented partisan warfare unseen since before the Civil War.
In 2006, Democrats won a landslide victory at the polls, sweeping to majorities in both houses of Congress. And then, the Democrats proceeded to do … hardly anything at all. Their agenda consisted mainly of halting George W. Bush’s domestic agenda. Even on the Iraq war, the unpopularity of which fueled the Democratic wave, the party did not make a serious effort to defund the campaign. Ultimately, Democrats funded a troop surge.

The rough equivalent would be if Republicans this year wound up expanding the Affordable Care Act to cover illegal immigrants. (To make the parallel between 2007 and the present more exact, we’d have to imagine that Republicans control the entire Congress, not just half, and that President Obama has lost about a quarter of his current popularity.) This scenario, of course, is unimaginable.

What are we to make of the contrast? One conclusion is that the GOP is the more disciplined, parliamentary party. I’ve made this case myself. But that is not the only implication, or the most disturbing. Why didn’t the Democratic Congress behave under Bush like the Republican-controlled House has behaved under Obama? Why didn’t it simply refuse to fund the Iraq war or to threaten financial cataclysm by holding the debt ceiling hostage unless Bush, say, raised taxes for the rich?

Democrats will have learned from history. It will not be pretty.

Thursday, July 28, 2011

Partisan Hackery on Magnificent Display

I read USA Today. Every day. In this morning's paper the editors published a very good op-ed entitled What would Reagan do? Not what today's GOP is doing.
The basic point of the article is that Reagan had a proven track record of compromising with Democrats and raising taxes when necessary on several occasions. He even decried threats to not raise the debt limit. All of this stuff is a matter of historical record and can easily be checked.

As is their custom, the paper offered the opportunity for an opposing viewpoint. They got one from Lee Edwards, a fellow at the Heritage Foundation and author of The Essential Ronald Reagan. Since the facts cited by USA Today are indisputable, I was curious to read what Edwards would offer in rebuttal.

His approach was pretty simple: ignore the USA Today article, botch some statistics, and misstate some data--a more confrontational person would accuse him of lying, but that's not my style. Quoting from his response:
Reagan raised the debt ceiling some 18 times because he was confident that in the long run, his program would create jobs and substantially increase government revenues as they did, nearly doubling between 1980 and 1990.
This is the same type of mendacity (whoops, I should watch my civility) that I complained about with Joe Scarborough and Jim DeMint. Edwards cites meaningless raw numbers that indeed show that revenues increased from $517 billion to slightly over $1 trillion in the 1980s, nearly doubling. However, if you simply index the numbers to inflation, which was much higher in the 80s than it is now, the increase is from $1.2 trillion to $1.5 trillion in constant 1985 dollars, an increase of only 26%. An even better metric is to look at revenues as a percentage of GDP. In 1980 they were 21%. The figure in 1990? 19%. In other words, the data shows exactly the opposite of what Edwards claims of them. Reagan's policies lowered, not raised, the amount of revenue the government collected compared to the size of the economy.

Next, he claims the following.
The act (Regan's tax cuts) produced 92 months of economic growth--the longest period of peacetime economic growth in the post-WWII period--and 17 million new jobs in the Reagan presidency. 
The 92 months he refers to is from the 2nd quarter of 1982 through the 3rd quarter of 1990. The government doesn't publish monthly GDP data. It provides quarterly data. The quarters both before and after this period saw a substantial decrease in growth. After a drop in growth in the 4th quarter of 1990, the U.S. did not experience a single quarter in which growth fell until the 2008 calamity, a period of 28 years! This is a substantially longer period of uninterrupted growth than the 92-month figure quoted by Edwards. Furthermore, in the Clinton administration alone more than 22 million jobs were created, again substantially outpacing the jobs-growth figure of the Reagan years. This performance occurred after Bush I and Clinton raised marginal tax rates on the wealthy, something Heritage Foundation fellows do not typically mention.

Finally,
Here at home, by the end of the Reagan presidency, the federal deficit as a share of GDP had fallen from 6.3% in 1983 to 2.9% in 1989.
Notice, he is aware of the % of GDP data. He just cites it selectively only when it supports his overall point and ignores it when it doesn't. Since the earlier statistic Edwards cited about government revenues compared 1980 to 1990, you might wonder why this statistic compares 1983 to 1989? He picks 1983 as his baseline (two years into the Reagan presidency) because the deficit was artificially high due to the deep recession the country was in. If you instead use as your baseline 1981, the year Reagan was inaugurated, the deficit as a % of GDP was 2.8%. And when he left office in 1989? It was 3.0%.

And what does Edwards have to say about the points made in the USA Today editorial regarding Reagan's willingness to compromise and to raise taxes when necessary that he was presumably rebutting? Nothing. He simply ignores them.

This is partisan hackery at its highest level.

Tuesday, July 26, 2011

What is our Political System Really Like?

I sometimes think that everything you need to know about our political system, present and past, is revealed in Monty Python's The Life of Brian. I used to think it was a comedy. Now it seems more like a documentary.

For example, what has the liberal state done for us?



 Or, how does Congress go about doing the people's business?




Finally, how should we understand the various factions within the new conservative movement?